David Hyde Pierce Never Left

David Hyde Pierce talks coming out to his husband, why queer fans still love ‘Frasier’ and his new film ‘Mouse’

David Hyde Pierce. Photo by Melanie Dunea.

Long before Niles Crane fussed his way into sitcom history, Tony and Emmy winner David Hyde Pierce was best friends with a fellow actor named Brian Hargrove. Neither knew the other was gay, until one night on the way to the movies, they both came out. (How that night ended, and how long it lasted, he’ll have to tell you himself.) Hargrove is now his husband.

It’s the kind of love story that didn’t come with a template, and Pierce sees a bit of it in “Mouse,” the quietly affecting coming-of-age drama from “Ghostlight” filmmakers Kelly O’Sullivan and Alex Thompson, now in theaters. Set in 2002, it follows Minnie (Katherine Mallen Kupferer), a teenager whose bond with her best friend, Callie (Chloe Coleman), is upended on the eve of their senior year, and it lets her figure herself out without making her queerness the whole point. That’s a world away from Pierce’s own small-town adolescence, when nobody talked about it at all. He plays Mr. Murdaugh, Minnie’s high school drama teacher, whose Broadway dreams never panned out and who channeled all that leftover joy into his students instead.

In our conversation, Pierce reflects on the teachers who opened doors for him, playing a gay pediatrician in “The Heidi Chronicles” at the height of the AIDS crisis and why, decades later, “Frasier” (opera tickets and all) still feels like home to so many queer viewers.

David Hyde Pierce in ‘Mouse.’ Photo courtesy of Independent Film Company.

When you look back at your own adolescence, what do you remember most about that period of figuring out who you were? And did you think about that while filming “Mouse”?

I thought about my high school and junior high school drama teachers, and what that process was of working with kids and imagining it from the kids’ point of view. And also, I thought about the drama teachers I’ve had after that, when I was in school and actually studying theater, because they open doors and windows and eyes and possibilities to you, whether you end up going into the theater or not. Mainly, I was grateful to get to be in their shoes.

Was there one teacher in particular who really helped you accept who you are?

I’m a different generation, so I didn’t know I was gay till I was at least in college, so it never occurred to me. I wasn’t really dealing with that issue. I got out of high school in 1977. Yeah, we rode horse-drawn coaches to school. [Laughs.]

I’m sure somewhere along the road, I was being taught by queer people, but I would not have known that at the time. Part of the reason I didn’t know was no one talked about it, at least in my small town growing up. In a funny way, I didn’t know queerness existed. Which is wild. This film takes place in 2002, which is a generation still removed from where we are now, in terms of people’s ability to talk about things or consider options.

The teacher you play in this movie just lets these kids be who they are, which in a way is the most powerful thing a teacher can do. How do you think he recognizes something in them that they might not recognize in themselves?

Minnie shows me something that I’ve never seen before. And there’s a particular moment in the film where she just astounds me. That’s important, to have a teacher who can be astounded by you. That they recognize something special about you. That’s important, because for some people, it’s just a job, and they’ve seen a million kids.

It seems to me, from some of the information you get about him, that maybe he had hoped to be, in a more professional way, an actor, that he was hoping to be in musicals on Broadway and it didn’t happen. And what’s cool about him is he plowed his enthusiasm and joy and curiosity into helping these kids find themselves.

Do you think we’re getting better at telling stories that let queer young people experience joy and possibility in an ordinary adolescence?

Well, I hope so. I hope that’s the direction we’re going in. What I like about this one in particular is that that does not seem to be the agenda of the movie. The way it tells that story is by having the connection that forms between the two characters.

You know, when I met my husband Brian, this was back in the day, and so at that time, he had a pretend girlfriend, because that’s what you did. So I didn’t know he was gay, and he didn’t know I was gay, and we became best friends. And we were friends for, oh, I think probably a year. We were both actors, we had the same agents, we would meet at auditions and stuff. Then one night, we were going to the movies, and I came out to him, and he came out to me, and as he says, I never left. That was that.

Because of the time, I didn’t really grow up understanding that much about the gay world. There weren’t patterns, there weren’t templates. For us, we just really liked each other, and then we really loved each other. There’s a million ways for relationships to happen, but that’s just how it happened for us, and I see that a bit in this film in how these two characters come together.

You’ve played some unforgettable characters in your career, particularly on television, but there’s something very appealing about seeing you in a smaller role in a more intimate, independent film. Is that a space you actively seek out, or do you tend to follow the stories and people that interest you?

It’s the latter. I mean, I love the format of independent films. I do a lot of theater as well, so I get to explore. And sometimes the plays are very intimate in very small theaters, and they’re equivalent to this kind of storytelling. It’s the character and the story and the people who I’m going to be working with, which is exactly what brought me to this film.




David Hyde Pierce in ‘Mouse.’ Photo courtesy of Independent Film Company.

You’re reminding me that before there was Niles, there was Peter Patrone in “The Heidi Chronicles,” a gay pediatrician whose story unfolds against the backdrop of the AIDS crisis. What did playing Peter mean to you at that point in your career?

It was a play written by Wendy Wasserstein. And Wendy Wasserstein’s best friend in the world was a playwright named Christopher Durang, one of the great comic voices of the contemporary theater. And my first professional job was a play called “Beyond Therapy,” which Chris wrote, and so I knew him very well. So I had the chance to, in a sense, be him.

Because in the play, the developing relationship between Heidi, this single woman, and Peter Patrone, a gay pediatrician, was like her meeting with Chris Durang. Some of it literally was taken from their original meetings. And so, to play out that relationship, which was about two people I cared about deeply, was really important to me. It wasn’t the only AIDS-related play that I was in, but anything that started to deal with that subject matter at that time felt important, because for so long, no one would talk about it. Friends were dying, and the government at that time was not interested in talking about it, and so anything that could raise awareness, and just let people know that they were being seen, was important.

We’re not telling stories about AIDS the way we used to. Has that made space for different queer stories, like “Mouse”?

Well, yeah, I think it certainly has. We also have “Elsinore” coming up. I remember when a producer friend of mine, Daryl Roth, was doing a revival of “The Normal Heart.” The play was written in the thick of the AIDS crisis, and there was a young guy who was my driver and was doing a show on Broadway, and he said, “Hey, can you tell me anything about the AIDS crisis? My boyfriend and I were talking about it, and we realized we don’t really know anything about it.” I said, “I’m gonna get you two tickets to ‘The Normal Heart,’ and that’s what you need to know.” First of all, I had to accept the fact that, wow, this is an adult person, but it’s been long enough that they know about it, but didn’t really know what happened, and the value of Larry Kramer’s play, aside from its theatrical value, but as a document of what we were going through at the very beginning of the crisis, that was huge.

Niles was heterosexual, but he didn’t exactly embody traditional masculinity, and there was plenty of humor on “Frasier” about people assuming he and Frasier were gay. As a gay man playing Niles, did you have a particular perspective on that humor?

You know, I thought it was funny, and one of the creators of the show, David Lee, is gay. And a few of the writers were, so it was always written from a very smart and knowing position. I thought it was actually kind of wonderful that you could have these characters who were involved, like they wanted to go to the opera, and people kept thinking they were gay. It wasn’t a theme of the show, it was just a recurring place that they could go to for a laugh, but it wasn’t at anyone’s expense. That’s what I would say.

Cruel humor was never a part of that show. I remember that for David Angell, our dear writer who we lost on September 11th, that was very important to him. When you don’t have a lot of time to put a script together, the easiest place to go for humor is to mean humor. And he said no, not on our show.

That show still resonates with a lot of queer people. As someone within the community who can speak from inside the work, why do you think queer viewers found, and continue to find, such a home in that world?

Honestly? Because it’s really good. And I would bring this back to the power of the storytelling of “Mouse”: whether we’re talking about a queer story, or the story of the grief or loss, or whatever the stories are that we’re dealing with, when things are told as beautifully, as skillfully, as wisely, as compassionately as they are in shows like “Frasier” or in a film like “Mouse,” then almost anyone can feel at home.

“Will & Grace” is just one of the greatest things that was ever on TV and plenty of straight people loved “Will & Grace.”  The focus and joy of that show was celebrating a very gay, queer world. I have heard this from many different kinds of people talking about “Frasier”: that they just felt safe watching the show. They knew it was smart, they knew it was funny. And even now, with the reruns, they can go back to it, and it just makes things feel all right.

When you think about your younger self — the aspiring actor, the young gay man figuring out where he fit — what do you think would surprise him most about the life and career you’ve built?

Every moment. Every moment would have surprised me, because I was not, and I never have been, and I’m still not, someone who thinks a lot about the future. It’s just not my personality. I tend to be happily absorbed where I am, and take opportunities as they come. So, it’s such a good question, but like I said, the whole thing, I think I would just look around at my life and say, “Really? This is where you ended up. How about that?”

This interview has been lightly edited and condensed for clarity.

Support local LGBTQ+ journalism

QBurgh is LGBTQ+ owned, operated, and reader-supported. Join monthly supporters who keep Pittsburgh-based LGBTQ+ journalism free for everyone.

100% LGBTQ+ Owned  |  Always free queer journalism  |  We accept all major credit cards, Apple Pay, and Google Pay  |  Cancel anytime.
Chris Azzopardi has interviewed a multitude of superstars, including Cher, Meryl Streep, Mariah Carey and Beyoncé. His work has also appeared in The New York Times, Vanity Fair, GQ and Billboard. Reach him via Twitter.